Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

Bath could see integrated transport if new bus cycle racks adopted

Bikes could be carried on front or back of buses for help with hills and long journeys

The MP for Bath is lobbying to have cycle racks installed on the front or back of buses in the city, to allow joined up journeys that are too long for bike alone.

Ben Howlett, Conservative member for Bath, has visited a company which produces the racks, along with the cabinet member for transport on Bath and North East Somerset Council, Councillor Anthony Clarke.

The move to have the racks installed was part of Mr Howlett’s general election campaign, as he said that Bath was too hilly for many cyclists.

MSPs call for bikes to be allowed on Scotland's buses

York cyclist ‘flabbergasted’ at not being allowed to take bike on bus

He told the Bath Chronicle: "These fantastic bicycle racks are already in place in some cities across North America, Australia and New Zealand and would be a great addition to Bath.

"It was great to see their versatility, being attachable to both the front and back of a bus, their ease of use, and importantly, that they would not disrupt the drivers' visibility.

"I would like to see a trial run across the city to gauge their impact on bus journeys, to assess how popular they are, and most importantly, to see how well they are received by my constituents.

"The Bath Park and Ride is an ideal option for the trial, giving commuters the chance to use public transport to get into the city, and still have the flexibility to travel to their specific location without needing a car.

"I will be lobbying the Department for Transport to ask for their support in bringing this trial to fruition.

"I am committed to stopping Bath stalling and so I want to make it easier for constituents and tourists to use public transport whether they are travelling in groups, with a buggy or with a bike.

"By making it easier for cyclists to use buses, this will reduce the number of cars on the road – something which is crucial to improve the roads and air quality across our beautiful city."

Mr Clarke said: "As a council we wish to encourage cycling for health and sustainability reasons, and the ability to move bikes around to make their usage more attractive should be encouraged.

"I would like to see a trial of these racks within the council area as soon as possible."

Add new comment

13 comments

Avatar
Bmblbzzz | 8 years ago
0 likes

This is significant for two reasons:
1) Bath's recently elected Tory MP sees the importance, whether from conviction or electability, of following in Don Foster's cycling-friendly path. So individual politicians can be persuaded to put in place pro-cycling measures, regardless of party policies, where local backing makes it worthwhile for them.
2) Bath and Bristol are national hubs of cycle publishing, ensuring lots of coverage and making it more likely the idea will spread.

Avatar
ron611087 | 8 years ago
0 likes

I just got back from cycling in the Netherlands. Whilst there I was faced with the problem of trying to go North across the estuary from Terneuzen without a big detour. Unusualy for the Netherlands, the N62 only accommodates motor traffic, there's no bicycle crossing.

Asking around I was directed to the bus terminus where I was assured a bus could take me through the tunnel. I was sceptical, but the bus driver helped me load my recumbent, with touring panniers, onto the bus, and then off again at the other side. All done with a smile.

It can be done.

Avatar
A V Lowe | 8 years ago
0 likes

In 1996 I imported the first of these racks to the UK - with the Cycle Challenge we got TRL to review the legislation and safety aspects of front mounted bike racks - free download of TRL592 gives the final report.

The report concluded that
1) UK buses have highest pedestrian collision rates per vehicle per year than any other class of vehicle - similar for EU.
2) a random bike placed on a bike rack on the front of a bus will completely fail to comply with EU safety regulations for forward facing sharp edges.
3) parts of the bike on the rack present a particular hazard in any collision with a pedestrian.
4) TRL also tested buses with/without front mounted bike racks & bikes to ENCAP car safety standards - the ONLY safety tests to date of a large commercial vehicle. The results were not good.
From this it was concluded that no DfT/DVSA sign off for front mounted racks was likely in Europe, but these racks were mounted on the rear of buses in Cumbria, Wales, Bristol, Devon, Scotland, Sheffield.

Issues with security (fast load/unload makes this an easy target for thieves), water and road muck (on bikes and on remote electrical locking systems), driver's responsibility for vehicle and loads, dwell time delays and protocols at bus stops (a rear rack adds, as a minimum, 40 seconds per bike, to the dwell time at a bus stop, when typically passengers can normally board in 2-3 seconds per passenger).

Having had experience of taking bikes on buses and coaches regularly since 1986 - nearly 30 years, I've concluded that the best way to test a service is to do what we have been doing for at least a decade with low floor buses - take the bikes inside. With the current legislation aiming to have 100% of service buses of this type by 2020, we will have a UK-wide bus network which can be immediately used, with minimal additional cost for cycle carriage, as is a standard condition for all bus services in the Western Isles, and already delivered for Brighton - a hilly city not unlike Bath in certain respects.

Coaches are even better - with underfloor hold-space - reports indicate that young BMX and MTB riders can fill up to 10% of the seats on coaches operating on several Highland routes, with their bikes in the underfloor hold.

Even unofficially TfL London Buses has been carrying bikes, as this young lady makes use of the 73 to Stoke Newington from Euston around 23.30 one night, to get home. Both this and SYPTE photo were taken over 10 years ago.

Avatar
CJSTEVENS1955 | 8 years ago
0 likes

Buses in Hawaii have these racks on the front. Works really well.

Avatar
Airzound | 8 years ago
0 likes

Crazy idea. Cyclists should just man up.

Avatar
kwi | 8 years ago
0 likes

I thought the DVA was against this due to increased injury risks in collisions with pedestrians.

Avatar
hampstead_bandit | 8 years ago
0 likes

//ep1.pinkbike.org/p4pb545500/p4pb545500.jpg)

On my first trip to Vancouver (B.C., Canada) I was pleasantly surprised by the experience of being able to load our heavy mountain bikes onto the front of a bus, and then being driven up to the base of Mt. Fromme to start our adventure on the North Shore trails.

Adding bicycle mounting racks to buses really expands the range of cycling, and has been successfully done in other countries for some years.

Avatar
levermonkey | 8 years ago
0 likes

I think for this to work effectively you would have to designate which stops can be used. In effect create transition nodes. If you allow a free for all at every stop then you would run the risk of alienating 'normal' bus users.

I can see this being an excellent way to enfranchise people living in rural areas who are off the bus routes. In effect people would cycle to their nearest node, be transported into the city centre and then cycle to their destination.

If you got this right then you could remove an awful lot of cars that are only there because their drivers have no realistic alternative.

I for one will be watching this with interest. Let's hope it comes to pass.

Avatar
fizrar6 | 8 years ago
0 likes

If you have a bike cycle. If you don't have a bike take the bus. Why would you want to take your bike on a bus? Surely Bath isn't so large that you can't cycle from one end to the other.

Avatar
nowasps replied to fizrar6 | 8 years ago
0 likes
fizrar6 wrote:

If you have a bike cycle. If you don't have a bike take the bus. Why would you want to take your bike on a bus? Surely Bath isn't so large that you can't cycle from one end to the other.

Bath is a tiny city, but presumably this will be for buses that go further afield?

Also, the town centre is pretty much in a natural bowl, and getting out again isn't easy for new and casual cyclists.

Myself, I'd rather see more energy spent on the park and ride schemes, and road schemes favouring peds and bikes.

Avatar
oozaveared replied to fizrar6 | 8 years ago
0 likes
fizrar6 wrote:

If you have a bike cycle. If you don't have a bike take the bus. Why would you want to take your bike on a bus? Surely Bath isn't so large that you can't cycle from one end to the other.

Same reason you might take a bike on a train. It allows you to commute more easily. Maybe using the bus to travel the bulk of the miles and the bike to cover the last few. Lots of people want to use their bikes but not everyone is up for longish commute and arriving sweaty. Anything that makes bike use easier and more convenient is to be welcomed.

Avatar
Metaphor | 8 years ago
0 likes

Standard practice on Swiss postal coaches (vertical racks on the rear). But then people never study Switzerland because they're too focused on the Dutch and Danish.

Avatar
StuInNorway replied to Metaphor | 8 years ago
0 likes

I saw no reference to the Dutch or Danish here, just American and New Zealand cities.
An important consideration is who is responsible for the bike when under transport, in teh USA it's the rider who has to secure it themselves, but does that include when the driver forgets about the rack and parks his bus 4" behind another one crushing the bikes ?
For security I'd like to see each "bike sport" on the busses have their own locking clamp, once loced onto the bike and key removed, bike can't fall off, but by the same boat, until the bike is in place the key can't be removed. Thereby meaning the rider has control of the bike throughout their journey.

Latest Comments