Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Survey suggests BMW drivers ‘most likely to show psychopathic traits’

Not the most scientific research, admittedly, but have a guess which brand‘s drivers rank second?

In findings that may not surprise regular readers of our Near Miss of the Day series showing close passes and the like by drivers on cyclists, a survey of 2,000 UK motorists suggests that people who drive BMWs, closely followed by Audi drivers, are most likely to be psychopaths.

Drivers of a range of makes and models of cars were asked to complete the ‘psychopath test’ which uses the answers to 12 questions of where they sit on the psychopathy scale, and thereby their likelihood of exhibiting abnormal, anti-social behaviour.

Now, psychopathy itself is a very serious psychological condition (see the end of this article) and we’re not going to kid ourselves that this is a peer-reviewed study published in a respected academic journal – in fact, it comes from the website Scrap Car Comparison, with the research conducted by 3Gem.

Moreover, with 20 car marques included, that’s an average of 100 drivers of each brand, hardly the biggest sample size, and rather than being based on any clinical assessment, the survey the results are derived from is based on multiple choice questions.

It does provide, however, a talking point, and it is certainly interesting that it’s drivers of the two brands most regularly called out by cyclists on social media, or on comments here, that top the list. Confirmation bias, anyone?

The results rank people on a scale running from 0-18 (no psychopathy) through 19-26 (psychopathy possible) and 27-36 (psychopathy likely), with the average score 6.6 (you can take the test yourself by following the link at the bottom of the blog page on the Scrap Car Comparison website – this writer scored 6).

BMW drivers scored an average of 12.1, with motorists driving Audi cars closely behind at 11.7 – both being the only marques significantly above average, with Fiat drivers in third place at 7.0, Mazda and Honda rounding out the top five at 6.4 and 6.3 respectively.

Even those highest average scores fall well within the ‘no psychopathy’ range, of course – although it may well be that some drivers scored higher.

The lowest scores, meanwhile, came from drivers of Toyota or Vauxhall cars, both on 4.7, followed by SEAT at 4.3, Kia at 4.2, and – bringing up the rear on 3.2, Skoda.

The results were also analysed by fuel type and colour of vehicle, and whether the car had a personalised number plate.

In terms of the former, people with electric cars scored 16.0, hybrids 9.8, diesel 7.0 and petrol 5.0.

Gold-coloured vehicles had the highest average score at 12.7, followed by brown at 12.2 – while silver, on 5.5 and red on 4.9 scored lowest (it’s worth pointing out here that silver is a very common paintjob on a BMW or Audi, given it is Germany’s traditional racing colour, as red is, say for Italy, or blue for France).

Meanwhile, owners of personalised number plates scored well over double what other drivers did, at 13.8 versus 5.3.

Dan Gick, managing director of Scrap Car Comparison said: “The popularity of true crime documentaries has resulted in a worldwide fascination with psychopaths. So, we were curious to discover whether there was any correlation between the car you drive and where you might sit on the psychopath scale.

“While our findings might back up some existing stereotypes of drivers who are unsafe on the road, it’s worth noting that none of the levels seen in our study were any cause for concern, and while certain TV shows or films might trivialise what it means it be a psychopath, it is a condition that should be taken seriously.

“For us, the number one priority is ensuring that whether you drive a BMW or a Skoda, you’re staying safe while driving so that your car doesn’t have to prematurely hit the scrap heap,” he added.

The company added at the end of its blog post:

While the findings from our study are interesting, and none of our drivers surveyed scored highly enough to suggest they do possess clear traits generally exhibited by a psychopath, psychopathy is a condition that affects lives, and therefore should be taken seriously.  

If you think you possess traits of psychopathy, or are worried about any of the themes or content discussed in this study, you can find more information and support at mind.org.uk.

Simon joined road.cc as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment

63 comments

Avatar
Skalamanga | 2 years ago
0 likes

Seems likely that it's because BMW and Audi are common as sales rep cars. Audi only gained the reputation when they started becoming fleet cars.

No idea why vauxhall were so far down the list, they're often far worse than the others.

Avatar
Ihatecheese | 2 years ago
2 likes

All a bit silly isn't it. Having to opt in to the test massively skews the results. BMW no longer sits on a pedestal (at least UK). Competitors caught up, manufacturers charge the same now and there is no longer the strong 80s style mid-level exec association. Now it's more blacked out windows and teenagers making dubious drop offs in 1 series cars.
Plebs will drive a old BMW or a Mazda. They both cost a grand. Just one might make it through the MOT whilst the other will eclipse the cost for a service.

BMW make some lovely cars. I just don't think they attract many more psychos. Just aspirational ones!

Avatar
armb | 2 years ago
2 likes

I used to own both an Audi and a Skoda, and I'm pretty sure I didn't switch to being or not being a psychopath depending which one I was driving at the time, so we should remember these are only generalisations.

But as a generalisation, no real surprise in the top two.

Though I do also wonder how Range Rover drivers would have scored if they weren't lumped in "Other".
https://metro.co.uk/2021/11/20/range-rover-mum-who-rammed-insulate-brita...
https://www.bigissue.com/news/the-mum-who-drove-her-range-rover-into-ins...

Avatar
Cycologist replied to armb | 2 years ago
1 like

Science requires generalisations, however, to generalise from qualatative experince is unscientific and is likely to be confounded by issues such as sample bias, the internal bias of the obsever(s) (conscious and unconscious) etc. you'd need to introduce controls to the study to.

Pretending this study has any scientific validity is absurd. It's utter garbage.

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to armb | 2 years ago
2 likes

armb wrote:

I used to own both an Audi and a Skoda, and I'm pretty sure I didn't switch to being or not being a psychopath depending which one I was driving at the time, .....

Well, you would say that, wouldn't you.....

Avatar
wycombewheeler replied to armb | 2 years ago
1 like

armb wrote:

I used to own both an Audi and a Skoda, and I'm pretty sure I didn't switch to being or not being a psychopath depending which one I was driving at the time,

ah but did you choose which one you would drive based on whetehr you were feeling like a psycopath?

Avatar
Owd Big 'Ead | 2 years ago
8 likes

I'm calling bullshit!
Around these parts it's twats in Land Rovers who are by far and away the biggest psychos.
Oddly enough the former Mrs Owd Big Ead drove a Range Rover Velar!
Coincidental?

Avatar
Cycologist | 2 years ago
0 likes

Here's a fairly limited NON scientific list of INFAMOUS SERIAL KILLERS Car manufacturers, (US bias).

Ted Bunndie   VW

Gary Leon Ridgway   FORD

Harold Shipmen    RENAULT

John Wayne Gacey   OLDSMOBILE 

Ed Gein  FORD

Manson Family (not SERIAL killers?)  FORD

Ian Brady   BRITISH LEYLAND

John George Haigh  ALVIS

Beltway Snipers's   CHEVROLET

David Berkowitz    FORD

Joel Rifkin  FORD

Bonnie and Clyde FORD 

Karst Roeland SUZUKI

Lonnie David Franklin Jr  VOLVO

Samuel Little    PONTIAC

Francis Heaulme   BICYCLE/TRAIN

Avatar
chrisonabike replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
3 likes

You can't get away with that - where's Hitler, Stalin, Mao...?

Avatar
Cycologist replied to chrisonabike | 2 years ago
0 likes
chrisonatrike wrote:

You can't get away with that - where's Hitler, Stalin, Mao...?

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Avatar
Cycologist replied to chrisonabike | 2 years ago
1 like
chrisonatrike wrote:

You can't get away with that - where's Hitler, Stalin, Mao...?

Very good. Prehaps on the 'mass mederer' list?  3

Pol Pot had a Merc.

Avatar
Cycologist replied to chrisonabike | 2 years ago
3 likes

Also, didn't Hitler invade Czechoslovakia, in part, to get hold of the Skoda factory?

Avatar
Jenova20 replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
0 likes

Cycologist wrote:

Also, didn't Hitler invade Czechoslovakia, in part, to get hold of the Skoda factory?

Yeah, but in exchange we got Fanta from that war...

Avatar
belugabob | 2 years ago
3 likes

Minis are the new BMW - err, hold on a minute...

Avatar
Cycologist replied to belugabob | 2 years ago
1 like

Ian Brady used a BRITISH LEYLAND mini van.

And, if there is such a thing, Ian Brady is probably a psychopath.

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
1 like

Cycologist wrote:

Ian Brady used a BRITISH LEYLAND mini van. And, if there is such a thing, Ian Brady is probably a psychopath.

I'll bet he's not....

Avatar
Cycologist replied to Captain Badger | 2 years ago
1 like

Would you? Why? I'll be interested to hear your argument.

Avatar
wtjs replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
1 like

I know what Badger's argument would be!

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to wtjs | 2 years ago
0 likes
wtjs wrote:

I know what Badger's argument would be!

Go on wt, were you right? 😉

Avatar
wtjs replied to Captain Badger | 2 years ago
3 likes

Go on wt, were you right?

Yes.

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
2 likes
Cycologist wrote:

Would you? Why? I'll be interested to hear your argument.

Cos he's dead....

Avatar
Sriracha replied to Captain Badger | 2 years ago
3 likes
Captain Badger wrote:

Cycologist wrote:

Ian Brady used a BRITISH LEYLAND mini van. And, if there is such a thing, Ian Brady is probably a psychopath.

I'll bet he's not....

Well, no, he's dead. But he was diagnosed in 1985 as a psychopath.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/may/19/ian-brady-psychiatric-nu...

Avatar
Cycologist replied to Sriracha | 2 years ago
4 likes

He was indeed diagnosed as a psychopath. However, there're problems with the construct.

So what is badger's argument? He was a psychopath? However, he's dead and in the context of the scientific evidence that consciousness does not transcend the 'laws' (or models) of physics, Ian Brady, therefore, can no longer be considered a psychopath?

Clever chap, CaptainBadger, certainly a cogent argument and outwitted me.  1

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
2 likes
Cycologist wrote:

He was indeed diagnosed as a psychopath. However, there're problems with the construct.

So what is badger's argument? He was a psychopath? However, he's dead and in the context of the scientific evidence that consciousness does not transcend the 'laws' (or models) of physics, Ian Brady, therefore, can no longer be considered a psychopath?

Clever chap, CaptainBadger, certainly a cogent argument and outwitted me.  1

Aaaww c'mon cyc. Just joshing with with you....

Avatar
Cycologist replied to Captain Badger | 2 years ago
2 likes
Quote:

Aaaww c'mon cyc. Just joshing with with you..

I Know. It was a good one, and I found it very amusing, hence my reply. 🙂

It's also why I up voted (liked) your reply/comment, I genuinely thought it amusing, helped break up the long day...

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to Cycologist | 2 years ago
2 likes

Cycologist wrote:

....I Know. It was a good one, and I found it very amusing, hence my reply. 🙂 It's also why I up voted (liked) your reply/comment, I genuinely thought it amusing, helped break up the long day...

Awww thanks Cyc. I liked yours toobroken heart

Avatar
Timsen | 2 years ago
3 likes

The point that jumped out at me was that electric cars scored 16 i.e the highest figure metioned for any category by some margin. Should this not be the headline ? 

Avatar
Joeinpoole replied to Timsen | 2 years ago
5 likes

I'd agree. I've certainly seen some absolutely crazy overtaking stunts by Tesla drivers in particular. They appear to believe that the incredible acceleration available to them makes them invulnerable ... or other drivers' concerns irrelevant.

There's an irony that Tesla owners probably pat themselves on the back for their 'green credentials' whilst actually demonstrating no empathy whatsoever for other road users.

Avatar
OnYerBike replied to Joeinpoole | 2 years ago
0 likes

Ditto - in my (anecdotal) experience, over the past few months I have noticed teslas jump rapidly to the top (or very near the top) of cars likely to be driven dangerously.  

Avatar
Awavey replied to Joeinpoole | 2 years ago
0 likes

maybe not invulnerable but theres no doubt they do stand up well in impact crashes, unbelievably the lorry driver only got 3pts.

https://www.edp24.co.uk/news/norfolk-tesla-wrecked-by-blocks-falling-fro...

Pages

Latest Comments