Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Study: Good cycling infrastructure makes roads safer for everyone

UK campaigners say US study proves the value of investing in high-quality cycle lanes

The authors of a study into road safety in a number of US cities say they are “surprised and encouraged” by the finding that protected cycling infrastructure not only makes roads safer for people on bikes, but for motorists too.

Researchers from the University of Colorado Denver and the University of New Mexico discovered that where local governments had spent money on high-quality cycle lanes, drivers became more aware of what was going on around them and were also more inclined to reduce their speed.

The result was a drop in casualty rates for all road users – although they noted that a similar effect was not seen in areas where bike lanes were simply marked out with paint, reports the Independent.

Co-author Wesley Marshall, a professor of civil engineering, told the newspaper: "Regular, painted bike lanes turned out to be non-significant. They may help in terms of bicyclist safety but weren't a factor when we focused on all road users.

"We are both surprised and encouraged by our results. When you think about travelling by different modes, a mile on public transport is about 20 times safer than a mile in a car, and a mile in a car is about 10 times safer than a mile on a bicycle.

"Thus, it stands to reason that a city (or country) with a lot of bicycling would be the least safe. However, the places with a lot of bicycling turned out to be some of our safest places – and not just for bicyclists."

The study focused on 12 large cities in the US, some of which have invested heavily in cycling infrastructure in recent years.

They said that between 1990 and 2010, deaths in road traffic collisions fell by 75 per cent in Portland, Oregon, by 61 per cent in Seattle, 49 per cent in San Francisco, 40 per cent in Colorado and 38 per cent in Chicago.

Nicholas Ferenchak, who co-authored the study, commented: "When we believed it was the old safety-in-numbers concept, that meant we had to figure out how to get more people on bicycles to make a city safer.

"That's not easy. But this research has boiled it down for city planners: create cycling facilities, and you'll see the impact."

Campaigners in the UK say that the research should prompt local authorities here to invest in high-quality infrastructure.

London Cycling Campaign’s Simon Munk told the Independent that the research findings showed it was “imperative for the mayor to crack on and deliver his pledge to triple the amount of segregated cycle lanes on main roads.

“Sadiq Khan is on track to do that,” he added, “but it is important that the next mayor continues to accelerate the pace of change.”

Cycling UK’s Roger Geffen said: "Investment in cycling is great value for reducing congestion, pollution, and physical inactivity," he said.

"The fact that it could also make our roads safer for everyone is another powerful argument for our government to increase substantially its investment in quality cycle provision.”

We've featured research from Professor Marshall on before. In 2015, he explored why some cyclists break the law. His answer? Because of the dominance of motor vehicles on the roads. 

Observing that cyclists who infringe traffic laws tend to be judged more harshly than drivers who do so, he called for city authorities to build more dedicated cycling infrastructure.

Simon joined as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Latest Comments

  • ChrisB200SX 1 sec ago

    I think that offending van may actual be someone down my road, he lost his 14-year-old dog on Friday. I shall check the number plate and maybe he's...

  • Adam Sutton 2 min 26 sec ago

    Getting rid of the tribalistic mentality that prevails would help. It doesn't have to be one or the other, cyclist or driver, especially outside of...

  • daviddowling 11 min 7 sec ago

    He googled his way home which led him this way and no steps are listed. There are also no warning signs notifying people of the steps ahead ...

  • ChrisB200SX 11 min 17 sec ago

    Even IF it isn't well lit, motorvehicles have 55W headlights for a very good reason.

  • chrisonatrike 12 min 22 sec ago

    I think you're correct.  They did build a mountain for cycling up though... Also it is possible to get up to a fair lick (60kmh+) in places.  And...

  • Rendel Harris 24 min 26 sec ago

    Chris the estate agent doesn't seem to have cottoned onto the best short-term solution which not only will stop the vandalism but also stop the...

  • chrisonatrike 25 min 1 sec ago

    Waverley you mean?  Never parked there.  I'd had a quick look when passing - didn't notice anything unusual but wasn't looking hard....

  • Rendel Harris 1 hour 6 min ago

    Such as joining in with other (now banned) trolls in a nice little bullygroup to perpetuate a tiresome fantasy that another poster with whom you...

  • qwerty360 1 hour 15 min ago

    Even if we struggle to hard limit capabilities, we could have similar classifications to motorbikes defined by combination of weight, acceleration,...

  • NOtotheEU 1 hour 22 min ago

    I only went out for a less than 5 minute ride to the PO to collect a parcel today. Got close passed by an Audi convertable that forced me into the...