Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

BBC to air helmet cam documentary

Controversial doco is called 'The War on Britain's Roads' - how will cyclists be portrayed?...

The BBC has announced that it will air its one hour special documentary on cyclists and motorists, fueled by helmet cam footage, at 9pm on BBC1 on 5th December.

The documentary has come under fire for appearing to be more than a little confrontational.

The broadcaster describes the programme as “an adrenaline-filled one-off film for BBC One."

They go on to say: “As more and more people take up cycling as a way of beating the traffic or just keeping fit on their commute, the potential for conflict between cyclists and drivers has increased massively,” the BBC said.

“Now cameras installed on bikes and in vehicles will use heart-stopping footage of interactions between road users to reveal a shocking picture of life on Britain’s roads. The film will follow current cases as they go through the courts and revisit the tragic stories of some of those who have lost their lives on Britain’s roads.”

The documentary has been made by Leopard Films, whose Chief Executive Officer, Todd Austin, commented: “This timely documentary highlights a growing issue on Britain’s roads, from the viewpoint of both the motorist and the cyclist. BBC One is the perfect home for this insightful and at times shocking film.

"Viewers are parachuted into the middle of the battle that is raging between two-wheeled road users and their four-wheeled counterparts."

Helmet cams are a mode of documentation, legal protection and downright fun for a growing number of cyclists, but portraying commuting as a 'battle', or 'adrenaline fuelled' goes against the vision the vast majority of riders would wish to see on the roads as more people take to two wheels.

Thomas Stokell, MD of Challenge for Change, which runs workplace cycle projects, told BikeBiz:

"There is clearly a risk here that this documentary will only portray cycling to be a dangerous, tragedy-filled activity. While clashes between people who drive cars and people who ride bikes do occur, it may seem to people who watch this documentary that they happen everyone time you ever ride your bike. This will clearly not be conducive to encouraging more people to take up cycling.

"Personally, I ride everyday, mainly in Bristol, but in cities all over the country as well, and I have hardly ever had a hostile confrontation with someone in a car. Positive interactions with other road users on one ride far far far outweigh any negative incidences.

"I really do hope that the documentary makers plan to show viewers at the beginning and the end of the documentary that hundreds of thousands of people ride everyday in the UK, and the vast majority of them have very pleasant rides. Why would they cycle if it wasn't highly enjoyable to do so?"

Add new comment

41 comments

Avatar
Arno du Galibier | 12 years ago
0 likes

"parachuted into the middle of the battle" Hmmm that doesn't smack of a composed, balanced and well informed representation of what commuting on a bike is like.  39

Manchester commuter too and I agree, can remember only a handful of occasions of vindictive behaviour, most people are just err.. normal.
Absentmindedness, SMIDYism and lack of appreciation of speed, distances, space etc.. now that's a different issue altogether.

Avatar
Steven_L replied to Arno du Galibier | 12 years ago
0 likes
Arno du Galibier wrote:

Manchester commuter too and I agree, can remember only a handful of occasions of vindictive behaviour, most people are just err.. normal.
Absentmindedness, SMIDYism and lack of appreciation of speed, distances, space etc.. now that's a different issue altogether.

I've found that when you catch people at the lights who've done something silly like cutting you up, or shouting out the window to tell you to use the cycle lane (which happened twice last week; the cycle lane filled with leaves & debris and totally unfit for purpose), they tend to back down significantly if you present a reasoned argument.

Now I've been knocked down twice this year, first time partially my fault as I was cutting up the inside of traffic and someone swung the door open without looking, second time a SMIDSY pulled across traffic to get down a side street; both times they were entirely reasonable.

The tone of the documentary is wrong by that title; by calling it a war, it sets out sides, and you can only be one or the other. Some drivers are dicks, so are some cyclists - but we're all human at the end of the day. I hope there is some balance in this, but I fear I'll be wrong.

Avatar
zanf replied to Steven_L | 12 years ago
0 likes
Steven_L wrote:

I've found that when you catch people at the lights who've done something silly like cutting you up, or shouting out the window to tell you to use the cycle lane (which happened twice last week; the cycle lane filled with leaves & debris and totally unfit for purpose), they tend to back down significantly if you present a reasoned argument.

I cant find the original but this is a great example of how a reasoned approach to bad road users completely takes the wind out of their self righteous sails:

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=65c_1352206981

I spoke with a friend who was asked early on to be involved with this docu and he turned it down, precisely because its a very divisive "us and them" approach. It wont be about how all road users are people [A major complaint i have about the Times campaign] and starts out from the angle that its a "war" (therefore has to be "won" and "lost" by the sides they have matched).

Its bad journalism, will do nothing to to make our cities and town more progressive and I bet you will have a rise in incidents of assault against cyclists shortly after it.

It will be interesting to view the reaction on twitter from all users during, and after, the airing of the programme.

Avatar
Joselito | 12 years ago
0 likes

Apols for cut n paste job but this is from Leopard Films's own website...

The War on Britain's Roads premieres Wednesday 5th December, 9pm BBC one

The War on Britain’s Roads combines footage captured by cyclists through helmet-mounted cameras, with interviews from cyclists, drivers and those affected by incidents on our roads. Viewers are parachuted into the middle of the battle that is raging between two-wheeled road users and their four-wheeled counterparts.

As thirty four million vehicles and thirteen million bikes all try to share the same crowded space, The War on Britain’s Roads provides a dramatic and unique insight into the unfolding tension and conflict. From everyday incidents that get out of hand between cyclists and motorists, to stories of near death experiences and fatal collisions, this timely documentary shows that the battle between two wheels and four has never been so intense.

The film presents both sides of the story, retelling dramatic incidents from both the cyclists’ and drivers’ points of view. It follows the cycle-mounted police as they chase down errant road users and record more than 3,000 offences every year from car and bike users alike. We even see a cyclist who is attempting to police the roads himself, handing out his own 'tickets' for anything from texting behind the wheel, to jumping a red light. A mother who lost her cyclist daughter in a fatal collision with a cement mixer tells the extraordinary story of her efforts to improve cycle safety on our roads, while a London black cab driver reveals how his own loss changed his opinion about cyclists forever.

Avatar
Gkam84 | 12 years ago
0 likes

I knew about this a week or so ago.

It looks interesting and some of the footage used comes from some of the better video cyclists around London.

Avatar
qwerky | 12 years ago
0 likes

It sounds like the program is going to further the 'us and them' mentality that is a growing threat to safety. Hopefully it will show that a person on a bike is actually a person, probably with a family, and not just some 'twat in lycra'.

I suspect its just going to be sensationalist twaddle rather than a real discussion of the issues.

Avatar
andyp | 12 years ago
0 likes

Frankly, I'm astonished.

I commute daily and rarely a week goes by without some t*sser in a car cutting me up severely then getting bent out of shape if I have the cheek to complain.

Manchester daily commuter here, can probably count on the fingers of one hand such incidents in the past 7 years. What are people getting up to?

Avatar
Ghedebrav replied to andyp | 12 years ago
0 likes
andyp wrote:

Frankly, I'm astonished.

I commute daily and rarely a week goes by without some t*sser in a car cutting me up severely then getting bent out of shape if I have the cheek to complain.

Manchester daily commuter here, can probably count on the fingers of one hand such incidents in the past 7 years. What are people getting up to?

Ditto me - don't come up against much wankerage from drivers on my commute at all, beyond not indicating (pedestrians thoughtlessly striding into the road without looking are my commuting issue #1).

Weekend sorties out of the city are a different matter...

Avatar
matthewn5 replied to Ghedebrav | 12 years ago
0 likes

Second that. Mostly uneventful commute, main annoyance is drivers turning left without indicating, but you can avoid that with caution at junctions.

It does make me wonder if the shouty type cyclists are those who pack helmet cams.

Avatar
mad_scot_rider | 12 years ago
0 likes
Quote:

Personally, I ride everyday, mainly in Bristol, but in cities all over the country as well, and I have hardly ever had a hostile confrontation with someone in a car

Frankly, I'm astonished.

I commute daily and rarely a week goes by without some t*sser in a car cutting me up severely then getting bent out of shape if I have the cheek to complain.

Avatar
georgee | 12 years ago
0 likes

What's the bet they open with footage from an alleycat race (probably from a foreign country).

Pages

Latest Comments