It’s like clockwork isn’t it, this helmet debate? Last year, the talk was fuelled after Dan Walker’s crash in Sheffield and him thanking his helmet for saving his life. Now, a full year and some months on, we’ve had celebrity chef and TV presenter Gordon Ramsay urge all cyclists to wear helmets, no matter how short their journeys be, after suffering a really bad crash leaving him with a horrible purple patch of bruise on his abdomen.
> Gordon Ramsay says helmets are “crucial” for cyclists no matter “how short the journey is”, after accident leaves him with a terrible bruise
Meanwhile, like a twisted work of fate, the foul-mouthed chef's appeal has coincided with the Dutch government calling on cyclists to wear helmets and even the local authorities running discount campaigns to encourage cyclists to buy helmets, with the national transport ministry set to publish guidelines on voluntary helmet use.
So it was only a matter of time before the UK media joined the dots and asked the question: “Should helmets be mandatory for cyclists?”
And perhaps the first one to bite the bullet was yesterday’s BBC Radio Scotland show Mornings with Stephen Jardine, who spoke to Anna Holligan, the BBC’s correspondent in the Netherlands, famous for setting up a mobile broadcasting studio called The Bike Bureau on a cargo bike.
“I wouldn’t normally talk about this subject unless it was with you because it’s so sensitive,” she said. “And before we even explain what it looks like here, I have to just give you a bit of culture clash introduction to cycling in the Netherlands because I’m talking to from my saddle where I spend so much of my time.
“The Dutch are absolutely not perfect when it comes to cycling by any measure and there’s been a rise in accidents here too. But still people don’t wear helmets usually because they feel that the infrastructure gives them the protection. So the idea that they would have to put on any kind of body armour before they get on their bike in the morning is just kind of alien.”
> BBC journalist corrects cargo bike critics, points out it "replaced my car" and saved "£1,000 in fuel"
Holligan mentions that while her daughter wears a helmet when cycling in the Netherlands, she herself doesn’t. When asked if she feels compelled to wear one when back in Edinburgh, her hometown, she replied: “100 per cent. Partly because you don’t have the segregated lanes, partly because you’re sure here in the Netherlands that most drivers are also cyclists so they take extra care.
“Here, cyclists have protection under the law. If there’s an accident, there’s a presumption that the driver is at fault rather than the cyclist so it tends to make drivers pay extra attention. There, you don’t have a bike lane to protect you, you don’t have a segregated roundabout to make sure you’re not coming into contact with cars. I’m sorry to say, when I go home, it does still feel at times like you’re battling with drivers.”
> Why is Dan Walker’s claim that a bike helmet saved his life so controversial?
Jodi Gordon from Cycling Law Scotland was up next on the show, and Jardine doesn’t waste when much time, getting straight to the point and asking: “Should helmets be mandatory here in Scotland?”
Gordon said: “No, I don’t think they should be. It has to come down to a choice and I think it will be counter productive if we’re trying to encourage people on to bikes and then we made it mandatory for people to wear helmets.
“I think rather than victimise cyclists and they should have some kind of protective headgear when they’re out on their bike, why don’t we look at what’s causing the incidents and how we can reduce those and increase road safety generally for everybody using the road network… Then we can give people the choice whether they wish to wear the helmet or not.
“There’s not as clear research when it comes to cycling helmets. There’s conflicting research as to what speed it can protect you up to, some say it’s 12mph, some say it’s 30mph. Until that is clear, it makes it difficult for people to have informed decisions and to make that compulsory.”