Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

TECH NEWS

Rob English’s head-turning single-sided Project Right bikes

Oregon-based framebuilder on his single-sided creations

Rob English has been consistently making some of the finest steel road bikes over the years. We’ve highlighted a fair few of them, including his NAHBS winners, as they have always been bikes that have stood out for some reason or another. Whether it was the 5.8kg superbike or the Naked time trial bike, they’ve always turned heads. His Project Right bikes are something else, though, because half the frame and fork is missing!

English Cycles 5.8kg carbon and steel superbike

The idea for producing a single-side frame and fork came about in 2012 at the request of a customer who asked Rob to produce something a little bit different. And different the bike certainly is. We can't think of many bikes that only have half a fork and no seatstays to chainstays on the non-drive side. Well, apart from the famous Lotus 108.

rob english project right 2.jpg

To make it possible, Rob first modelled the frame using 3D CAD computer software to ensure it was possible to build a frame with several key parts of it missing. He tells us that the high stiffness of steel means that increasing the tube diameters actually made it fairly straightforward to produce a single-sided bike, but he still had to make some changes compared to a regular frame to make it all work. 

He built the frame and fork using oversized tubing sleeved at the base to add extra stiffness and strength, with a triangular profile for the chainstay where it meets the bottom bracket, providing additional stiffness. Because the chainstay sits between the drivetrain and rear wheel, Rob tells us “the drive has hardly any leverage to exert lateral forces onto the axle.”

rob english project right.jpg

- Rob English’s single-sided Project Right bike

The rear hub is a custom design with a one-piece axle and shell. “The bearings are press-fitted into the tube at the end of the chainstay – the axle slides through this, then the freewheel carrier is  splined onto the end of the axle with a cap bolts in place to hold everything together,” explains Rob. The bike pictured is a singlespeed with a belt drive, and the design allows easy belt installation. 

Compared to the lengths he went to in developing the frame, he says the fork was much easier. One-sided forks are nothing new, Cannondale has been pushing its Lefty, both suspension and rigid, forks for many years now. Rob has used a Lefty-style aluminium axle which press fits straight into a socket at the base of the leg and the fork crown clamps onto a one-piece stem and steerer tube. 

rob english project right 3.jpg

You can see more details on that original bike right here.

Any concerns that the bike will be all floppy and flexy are quickly dispelled by Rob. “I haven't actually measured any deflection to give you stiffness data; I can just report that there is no flex when riding,” he tells us. 

He adds: “stub axles are very common on vehicles - when was the last time you saw a car with the hub supported on both sides? I think we are just not used to seeing them on bicycles, although it has been done before, notably, on many of Mike Burrows designs (from the original Lotus to the Giant Halfway).

English_multi_Xiangyu_PR_web_011_8710.jpg

We also asked Rob if there are any weight savings with this unique design. “No real weight saving,” he says. “With further refinement, this might be possible, but the oversize single tube ends up weighing about the same as a regular pair of tubes.

“Honestly there is not a compelling reason to build a bike this way (apart from fixing punctures without removing the wheels), but for the rider who wants something completely eye-catching and unique, it is an option. For me, it was a nice challenge to tackle both as a design and fabrication project”

English_multi_Xiangyu_PR_web_005_8679.jpg

Yet it appears to have become popular. Rob has built a few since that original bike four years ago. There was even a 29er mountain bike version which was displayed at NAHBS and looks absolutely stunning. And he's since built two more road bikes, the latest has been painted to match the Paul Smith Land Rover Defender. The one-off Defender was created by Sir Paul Smith to celebrate its heritage, and features 27 different colours across the various body panels. There's a good video with Sir Paul Smith talking about the reasons for the creative direction of the special Land Rover here. 

Rob will be over for the Bespoked show next April, and hopefully, he'll bring a few bikes with him. You can see more of Rob's work at www.englishcycles.com

David worked on the road.cc tech team from 2012-2020. Previously he was editor of Bikemagic.com and before that staff writer at RCUK. He's a seasoned cyclist of all disciplines, from road to mountain biking, touring to cyclo-cross, he only wishes he had time to ride them all. He's mildly competitive, though he'll never admit it, and is a frequent road racer but is too lazy to do really well. He currently resides in the Cotswolds, and you can now find him over on his own YouTube channel David Arthur - Just Ride Bikes

Add new comment

25 comments

Avatar
stuartatbikefix | 7 years ago
0 likes

Mike Burrows' explanation of the advantages is here

Avatar
Zebra | 7 years ago
0 likes

It's alright....

Avatar
stuartatbikefix | 7 years ago
0 likes

Read Mike Burrows on the rational reasons here

Avatar
DrJDog | 7 years ago
0 likes

Front disc and fixed, why bother with the rear brake at all?

Avatar
fukawitribe replied to DrJDog | 7 years ago
0 likes
DrJDog wrote:

Front disc and fixed, why bother with the rear brake at all?

The hub is described as having a freewheel carrier I'm guessing it's not a fixie.

Avatar
mike the bike | 7 years ago
0 likes

 

My engineer father would have said, "It may be clever but is it necessary?"  And, in the case of the Lefty, I agree with him.  But this is different.  Somehow.

Avatar
Ziptie | 7 years ago
0 likes

Fantastic and very interesting design exercise, but unless it saves weight, adds stiffness or reliability, I can't see it becoming mainstreem. But I guess the fact it will never be mainstreem is part of the attraction.

Cannondale's Lefty gear has it's fans, but they are very "niche"

Avatar
joules1975 replied to Ziptie | 7 years ago
0 likes

Ziptie wrote:

Fantastic and very interesting design exercise, but unless it saves weight, adds stiffness or reliability, I can't see it becoming mainstreem. But I guess the fact it will never be mainstreem is part of the attraction.

Cannondale's Lefty gear has it's fans, but they are very "niche"

not sure the lefty should be called niche, but even if it is it's not because of the design having fundamental flaws, but more the fact that they can't be fitted to many frames so sell few aftermarket, and my guess is that cannondale have the patents tied down pretty tightly meaning it's hard for anyone else to produce a single sided suspension fork that could compete.

the lefty fork is actually very good.

Avatar
muhasib | 7 years ago
0 likes

So the downtube says 'ENGLISH' next to a design of the Union Flag,  someone needs to sit through Sheldon's 'fun with flags' until they educate themselves as to the appropriate design to use.

Avatar
ClubSmed replied to muhasib | 7 years ago
2 likes

muhasib wrote:

So the downtube says 'ENGLISH' next to a design of the Union Flag,  someone needs to sit through Sheldon's 'fun with flags' until they educate themselves as to the appropriate design to use.

English is the name of the designer/builder of the frame not the origin of the bike. I am not aware of many surnames carrying their own flag  1

Avatar
Johnnystorm replied to muhasib | 7 years ago
1 like
muhasib wrote:

So the downtube says 'ENGLISH' next to a design of the Union Flag,  someone needs to sit through Sheldon's 'fun with flags' until they educate themselves as to the appropriate design to use.

I could be wrong but despite his current location I think that Rob has the surname English and originated in the UK so the flag might represent his background rather than his surname.

Avatar
Rapha Nadal replied to muhasib | 7 years ago
0 likes

muhasib wrote:

So the downtube says 'ENGLISH' next to a design of the Union Flag,  someone needs to sit through Sheldon's 'fun with flags' until they educate themselves as to the appropriate design to use.

Someone needs to dig a little deeper.

Avatar
Rapha Nadal | 7 years ago
0 likes

Really cool.  I like the detailing on the fork on the multicolured one.

Avatar
peted76 | 7 years ago
0 likes

I think it looks great, face it anyone who's going to buy a bike like this is never going to want it in stealth colours.. however I do think mixing the brakes disc and rim is a bit franken-bike - can't think of a way around it though.

 

Avatar
bikebot | 7 years ago
0 likes

The rear hub is interesting, even on a conventional frame that might be a  cheaper/simpler/stronger way to handle a belt drive without a break in the chainstay. It looks slim, probably 100mm as a front wheel. Is alignment less of an issue with belts than chains?

The one thing I can't figure out, is what's going on with the brakes.  Two brake levers, with a cable  visbile entering the downtube, but no rear brake. It's a fixie, so what's that cable doing?

Avatar
lewiskinch replied to bikebot | 7 years ago
0 likes

bikebot wrote:

The one thing I can't figure out, is what's going on with the brakes.  Two brake levers, with a cable  visbile entering the downtube, but no rear brake. It's a fixie, so what's that cable doing?

 

If you maximise the first photo you can see an under the chainstay brake, as used on TT or aero bikes.

Avatar
hennahairgel replied to bikebot | 7 years ago
1 like

bikebot wrote:

The one thing I can't figure out, is what's going on with the brakes.  Two brake levers, with a cable  visbile entering the downtube, but no rear brake. It's a fixie, so what's that cable doing?

Look at the first pic; it's under the chainstay/BB

Avatar
bikebot replied to hennahairgel | 7 years ago
0 likes

hennahairgel wrote:

bikebot wrote:

The one thing I can't figure out, is what's going on with the brakes.  Two brake levers, with a cable  visbile entering the downtube, but no rear brake. It's a fixie, so what's that cable doing?

Look at the first pic; it's under the chainstay/BB

Yep, found it, thanks. That was simple.

Avatar
Artem | 7 years ago
1 like

What about rear brake? And how he managed front brake on the right side?

Avatar
TheFatAndTheFurious replied to Artem | 7 years ago
1 like

Artem wrote:

What about rear brake? And how he managed front brake on the right side?

Looks like the rear brake is a direct-mount rim-brake affair nestled behind the bottom bracket.

Clever, but not for me! I hope the owner is very happy with it though.

Avatar
fukawitribe replied to TheFatAndTheFurious | 7 years ago
0 likes

TheLonelyOne wrote:

Artem wrote:

What about rear brake? And how he managed front brake on the right side?

Looks like the rear brake is a direct-mount rim-brake affair nestled behind the bottom bracket.

Clever, but not for me! I hope the owner is very happy with it though.

..and the front is just a normal caliper put on the other side (so the pad adjustment wheel that is usually next to the spokes is now on the outside).

Avatar
SoBinary | 7 years ago
5 likes

Honestly there is not a compelling reason to build a bike this way

Actually if you want to use a belt to drive rather than a chain (that can be split) there is EVERY reason to do so, in fact it is an elegant engineering solution... otherwise you need a way of splitting the frame to replace the belt.  Motorbikes have a lot more power going through them and quite a few have a single trailing arm.

 

Avatar
pjclinch | 7 years ago
3 likes

The Lotus 108 and, errrr, quite a lot of the stuff Mike Burrows has made since.  The 8 Freight cargo bike, the Giant Halfway folder, for example.

It makes good structural sense if you do it properly.  Those "car" and "truck" things you occasionally see about the place with one-sided wheel support seem to manage okay...

Avatar
Peowpeowpeowlasers | 7 years ago
3 likes

I love Rob English's stuff, how unique and interesting his bikes look.  This is no different, but that colour scheme is pure cancer.

Avatar
brooksby | 7 years ago
1 like

No.  I'm sorry, but, just: no

Latest Comments