The Santini Gravel Women's Bib Shorts promise comfort, durability, and functionality – and I'm a lover of the cargo pocket design. But after wearing these bibs over more than 1,000km, while they have been very comfortable in many respects, they also fall short in some areas, including long-ride comfort and durability.
For more options, check out our guide to the best cycling bib shorts.
> Buy now: Santini Gravel Women’s Bib Shorts for £143 from Santini
The most important thing for any bib shorts is comfort, and though Santini has really excelled in that with the gel-infused C3W women-specific seat pad, which I found super comfy from the very first ride, there are a few areas where they could be better for longer rides.
The shorts are crafted from gabardine fabric, which includes 25% elastane to keep it stretchy, and, as Santini promises, it feels nice against the skin. Santini says this blend also gives excellent abrasion resistance, which has held true no matter how many bushes I've ridden through. The way the fabric is stitched together, however, is not ideal for the skintight fit.
The seams running from the leg gripper to the waist over the thigh are not sewn flat but overlocked, and they protrude and press into the thighs. Although it's not something I'd particularly notice when riding (except for a few eight-hour-plus rides), after a longer ride it took quite a while for the pressure marks to fade from the skin. Comparing them with other cycling bib shorts at this price point, I feel not using flatlock seams is a big oversight from Santini, and I imagine it could even cause chafing for someone with more sensitive skin.
The leg grippers are another area where these bibs and I don't really get along too well. I've grown to really like bib shorts without silicone grippers because they never snag on the skin or make pulling the shorts on difficult. Santini has kept things more traditional and added quite a wide gripper with honeycomb-structured silicone inside. Because of the width (and flatlock seam attaching them to the thigh part of the shorts), they do not dig into the thighs too much, but they grip so well that if you want to adjust them at all it's not easy, and pulling the shorts on is a bit of an ordeal.
The cargo pockets – one large on each thigh – have not fared too well through my gravel adventures, either. Both pockets, after a few months of testing, have quite a few tears in them, and I'm not entirely sure what has caused them all. I mostly use the right-hand pocket for storing my phone and the left for snacks and random spares I might carry on my rides, or my keys.
Aside from the fragile mesh-like fabric, the size of these pockets is perfect – very similar to the ones on Rapha's Cargo bib shorts – and because of the stretch you can really fit quite a few snack bars in if you want to. The pockets also have reflective strips, too, which are great for added visibility.
There is an additional large pocket on the lower back, which I used for spares when I wore a more casual shirt without rear pockets. It's made of the same material as the side cargo pockets, and the upper edge has a short seam in the middle (kind of dividing the opening into two) making sure it won't stretch down when you've loaded it full.
The overall fit of these shorts is quite snug and compressive, but not in a restricting way. I tested the size XS from a range that spans from XXS to XL, and would say they are true to size.
The leg length is similar to shorts from Rapha or Pas Normal Studios, and I found the height of the shorts part to be good, sitting just below my belly button at the front, and held well in place by the snug straps that connect to a mesh-like fabric at the upper back/neck area. I wouldn't mind the front coming higher up, especially if I chose to wear these bibs a lot in the winter, but they do offer enough coverage that I didn't have a gap between my jersey and the shorts at my belly.
As these shorts are aimed at off-road use I've been assessing them more closely in terms of washability because, let's be honest, on gravel roads you'll end up with a lot of grit on your back if you forget your mudguard... On this front, the bibs have performed well, washing easily in a short, 30-degree cycle. The chamois has started to discolour a little, but I think that is mostly down to the chamois cream I use, and happens with almost all pads.
The little Santini logo patch on the lower back has started to come off, though – perhaps because of all the washing or just not being stitched on well enough.
Value
There's a lot to like about these bib shorts, but the non-flatlock stitching and durability of the pockets make the £143 price tag a little hard to justify. That said, cargo bib shorts do seem to be some of the most expensive bib shorts out there.
I reviewed the Assos Uma GTC Bib Shorts last year and really rated their chamois structure, though the pockets were a bit too small, and they're £215.
I've also spent a lot of time riding in Rapha's Women's Cargo bib shorts which cost a whopping £240 (we tested the non-bib Cargo version a few years back), but these have a lovely baselayer-like upper (though it makes it a bit hard to undress), and the pockets are super spacious.
> Read more road.cc reviews of women’s cycling kit
Two closer contenders to the Santini Gravel bibs are the Endura Women's GV500 Reiver Bib Shorts, which go for £130 and even feature an easy-pee construction – something of a rarity in that price bracket – and the yet-to-be-defeated, in my eyes, Castelli Free Unlimited Women's Bib Shorts. They're not cheap at £190 but remain my favourites to date, mainly because of the lack of silicone leg grippers and very durable pocket structure – I've been riding them for a good two years without any tears – and a snug but functional easy-pee system.
Conclusion
Overall, while the Santini Gravel Women's Bib Shorts are not the priciest cargo option out there, I think I'd wait for a revised version before pressing on and buying them – I'd hope for flatlock seams, at least. The chamois is really super comfy, especially on bumpy gravel roads, and the pocket space is ample, but there is room for improvement.
> Buy now: Santini Gravel Women’s Bib Shorts for £143 from Santini
Verdict
An excellent chamois, but plenty of room for improvement elsewhere
Make and model: Santini Gravel Women's Bib Shorts
Tell us what the product is for
Santini says: "Our women's Gravel bib shorts are the perfect choice for long rides on your gravel bike or for all off-road adventures"
Tell us some more about the technical aspects of the product?
Santini says: "Made with the exclusive 200 g / m2 Gabardine fabric with 25% elastane with a typical dense diagonal rib design, they have excellent abrasion resistance while remaining incredibly soft on the skin and guarantee a light compressive action.The front bibs are in ribbed elastic with back in breathable mesh. Two pockets on the bottom of the leg and two additional pockets on the lower back offer an excellent load capacity to carry the essentials for your rides. Reflective logos offer better visibility in low light conditions. The elastic grip at the bottom of the leg has a honeycomb silicone structure that guarantees perfect sealing and the C3W women's specific seat pad offers maximum protection from shocks thanks to its gel structure making it ideal for long hours in the saddle."
Santini also gives this temp range: +18/+35
Rate the product for quality of construction:
6/10
They're well made – mostly – but I'd expect more flatlock stitching for maximum comfort, and the Santini badge has pretty much come off in the few weeks I've been wearing them.
Rate the product for performance:
7/10
Rate the product for durability:
4/10
The pockets aren't as durable as I'd expect; I've not experienced similar issues with holes in other cargo bibs, so I think the material needs to be a little stronger. Also, the logo patch coming unstitched is a little disappointing.
Rate the product for fit:
9/10
Rate the product for sizing:
9/10
Rate the product for comfort:
6/10
The chamois and overall fit are great, but the leg grippers and seams aren't the best for long-distance comfort.
Rate the product for value:
4/10
These bib shorts have some good features but their lack of flatlock stitching and durability issues with the pockets make the £143 price hard to justify.
How easy is the product to care for? How did it respond to being washed?
Wash well even after really mucky rides, though the pad does start to show marks from chamois cream.
Tell us how the product performed overall when used for its designed purpose
These are (mostly) well-made bib shorts and the pad is really comfortable, but some details seem to have been overlooked, such as not using flatlock seams or making sure the pockets are durable enough.
Tell us what you particularly liked about the product
Good size pockets, nice compressive fit and true to size.
Tell us what you particularly disliked about the product
The lack of flatlock stitching for maximum comfort on really long rides.
How does the price compare to that of similar products in the market, including ones recently tested on road.cc?
There are more expensive cargo bib shorts, such as the £215 Assos Uma GTCs, which have a great chamois (but small pockets), and the £240 Rapha Women's Cargo bib shorts, which have a lovely baselayer-like upper and super-spacious pockets, but Endura's Women's GV500 Reiver Bib Shorts are £130 and have an easy-pee design, and though Castelli's Free Unlimited Women's Bib Shorts are £190, I've yet to find better.
Did you enjoy using the product? Yes
Would you consider buying the product? No, unless the seams were improved.
Would you recommend the product to a friend? Maybe – if they were heavily discounted you could overlook the stitching/durability issues.
Use this box to explain your overall score
The Gravel bib shorts have a lot of promise and potential, but I feel some important details have been overlooked, for the money. The chamois is super comfy and the fit is great, but the pocket durability and lack of flatlock stitching need to be addressed before these are more than average overall, and anywhere near on a par with the best women's cargo bib shorts.
Age: 30 Height: 164cm Weight: 52kg
I usually ride: Specialized Tarmac Sl6 My best bike is:
I've been riding for: 5-10 years I ride: Every day I would class myself as: Expert
I regularly do the following types of riding: cyclo cross, commuting, touring, general fitness riding, mtb, Ultra-distances
I don't believe him. Wiggins Rights Ltd is the top company (it owns 101 Ride Ltd, which owns New Team Ride Ltd). It's owned 98% by Brad, 1% by his...
Yes - or:...
wot no radar? good job they're on a black friday special at the mo...
Tweak no 1 then. The tag would need to beep at around 15mph getting more frequent as it approaches 20. It would come with an advisory note to...
That will be along in a week or so in the annual reboot of the "All I want for Christmas is... not this" article along with the Park Tool pizza...
For that money, I'd go to Matthew Sowter - https://www.saffronframeworks.com/
The problem with most jeans (i.e. not cycling designed ones) is that they've got the seam where it can intefere/chafe with the saddle. Also, cotton...
Why do the police have to wait for the council to install CCTV cameras? Can't they go and put one there themselves - it doesn't even have to be a...
I'm not sure commercial success is even particularly high on his list of priorities for it - it's much more about the leverage it gives him for...
Rather artistic photo of this (driverless) car that has ended up on its roof on a dead straight road in Bradford....