Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

“Best Parisian driver detected”: Olympic silver medallist Anna Henderson collides with Shimano neutral service car during road race, as Lizzie Deignan reveals “medial emergency” and night in hospital days before strong Team GB showing

Henderson and Deignan both played a pivotal role in teeing up a potential medal chance for British teammate Pfeiffer Georgi, who finished fifth behind solo winner Kristen Faulkner

A strong all-round display from Great Britain’s three-rider squad at a thrilling Olympic women’s road race may not have resulted in a medal on Sunday afternoon, but Pfeiffer Georgi, Anna Henderson, and Lizzie Deignan’s ambitious, attacking ride on the streets of Paris was enough to earn classics specialist Georgi a well-deserved fifth place on the Trocadéro, around a minute and a half behind American Kristen Faulkner’s brilliantly timed solo triumph.

Team GB’s impressive performance – they were the only nation to place all their riders in the ultimately winning split that formed in the wake of Chloé Dygert’s pivotal crash with 48km to go, with Georgi, Deignan, and Henderson all finishing in the top 13 – wasn’t without its hiccups, however, both before and during the race.

In the closing stages of the race, after briefly being distanced from the elite group racing for the medals following a series of attacks, Henderson – the silver medallist in the time trial the weekend before – was chasing back through the race convoy when she collided with the Shimano neutral service vehicle, almost causing her to crash and forcing her to clip out of the pedals.

Controversy as GB cyclist hit by official car during Womens Olympic Road Race
byu/a-curious-monkey insports

In a video of the incident posted to Reddit, Visma-Lease a Bike rider Henderson can be seen making her way around a right-hand bend on the tight, urban finishing circuit in Paris, surrounded by official race cars and motorbikes (a common sight in any professional road race), just as Polish rider and eventual tenth-place finisher Marta Lach pulls over soon after the corner with a puncture.

Spotting Lach’s mechanical problem, the driver of the blue Shimano neutral service car – which provides assistance to all riders if their own team car isn’t available – then veers over to the right to stop, just as Henderson speeds into the gap.

> What the hell is neutral service at the Tour de France?

The 25-year-old collides with the rear side of the vehicle, as one of the mechanics inside opens the door to service Lach, causing her to brake sharply and briefly unclip, before continuing her chase back to the leaders.

Anna Henderson, 2024 Olympic road race (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

Henderson and Deignan crest the now-iconic climb of Montmartre near the end of Sunday’s thrilling race (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

The clip has sparked some conversation on social media, with the blame for the incident seemingly divided between Henderson and the neutral service driver.

While many fans criticised the Shimano driver for his lack of awareness – one even sarcastically noting that the video has definitively found Paris’ best motorist – former Colombian pro Victor Hugo Peña, who rode for Lance Armstrong at US Postal for four years in the early 2000s, noted that riders making their way through the race convoy “can never pass on the right side”.

> Shimano responds to pro rider who lashed out at its neutral service, claiming she was denied assistance at World Championships road race

Sunday’s collision with Henderson marks the second time in a year that Shimano’s neutral service personnel have had an alleged effect on an elite women’s championship road race.

At last August’s world road race championships in Scotland, Luxembourg’s Christine Majerus lashed out at Shimano after claiming that she was denied neutral service assistance after puncturing in the first 10km of the race, forcing her to pull out “before it even started”.

However, Shimano responded to Majerus’ criticism – which included a plea for her social media followers to not buy from the Japanese components giant – by claiming that the staff in charge of the neutral service car in question “strictly adhered to the race convoy rules”.

And in 2015, the driver of one of the Shimano cars was responsible for a shocking crash at the Tour of Flanders, when he veered into Trek’s Jesse Sergent, causing the New Zealander to crash and abandon the race.

> “A TV camera is there to capture images and not to influence the race”: Mark Cavendish blasts Tour de France motorbike rider for putting him “out the back” after mechanical, as record-breaking sprinter fined for drafting behind team car

Meanwhile, vehicles of all kinds have played an increasingly worrying role in major races in recent years, especially at the Tour de France, where several incidents involving motorbikes straying too closely to the riders culminated this year in Mark Cavendish accusing a TV motorbike rider of interfering with his chase back to the peloton following a mechanical.

The prolonged and controversial return to the bunch during stage six of the race to Dijon ultimately saw the record-breaking Manx sprinter fined for drafting behind his team car, causing him to declare after the stage that “a TV camera is there to capture images and not to influence the race”.

“I’m alright, just about. I’m ready to chill out”

Beyond untimely collisions with race vehicles, Team GB’s build-up to the Olympic road race was also hampered by key rider and silver medallist at the 2012 road race Lizzie Deignan experiencing a “medical emergency” just 10 days before the event.

Speaking after the race, former world champion Deignan – who launched the move that pulled silver medallist Marianne Vos and fourth-place Blanka Vas clear – said her preparation for Sunday’s showpiece event was “absolutely abysmal”.

Lizzie Deignan, 2024 Olympic road race (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

(Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

“I got Covid during the Giro and raced by accident with it and really put myself in a hole. And then I was in hospital with a medical emergency 10 days ago, I spent the night in hospital. I’m alright, just about,” she told reporters at the finish, without giving any further details about what happened.

“So I knew that there was no final in the legs. I knew I had good shape, but I knew that after 120km I’d be struggling and I could see that Pfeiffer was feeling good.

“It’s been one of those build-ups where it’s hard to come into without the evidence of the work. It’s been an emotional rollercoaster. I’m ready to chill out.”

Pfeiffer Georgi, Lizzie Deignan, Anna Henderson, 2024 Olympic road race (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

(Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

Despite her fractured preparation, Deignan – who, alongside Henderson, bridged across to the lead group containing Georgi which formed after a crash split the peloton with under 50km to go – was one of the key instigators in pulling that ultimately successful group clear, driving it on the front in a bid to keep first Lotte Kopecky and then Lorena Wiebes at bay.

Deignan and Henderson then attacked several times in a bid to hammer home Britain’s numerical advantage and set up Georgi – whose own attack on the second ascent of Montmartre was quickly snuffed out – for a shot at the medals, the DSM-Firmenich rider eventually ceding to Faulkner and Kopecky the last time up the iconic cobbled climb, before outsprinting Spaniard Mavi García for a highly credible fifth place.

Pfeiffer Georgi, 2024 Olympic road race (Alex Whitehead/SWpix.com)

(Alex Whitehead/SWpix.com)

“From the outside it might have looked a bit odd,” Deignan, racing her final Olympic Games before retirement, said at the finish about Team GB’s attacking tactics. “But I thought, you know what, we’ve got three.

“Maybe from the outside you try and keep the three for as long as you can, but I knew actually the best thing I could do was establish that breakaway, give Pfeiffer a free ride, and as soon as Kopecky jumped across, that’s when I started attacking.

“They were complete suicide moves. I had no intention of riding away to a medal, because I was really struggling today with pain.”

Pfeiffer Georgi, Lizzie Deignan, Anna Henderson, 2024 Olympic road race (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

(Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

Meanwhile, Georgi said she was “little bit gutted” about missing out on a medal in Paris.

“I felt really good today. I was really hoping something special might happen and I’d be in a shout for the medals but the last time up the climb my legs said no, and I just saw them riding away,” the classics star said.

“It hurts a little but it’s my first Olympics, so I can’t be too disappointed with fifth. The Olympics is a completely different dynamic than at any other race. We’re never teammates on the road. So, it’s a combination of things that are new. It was a really unpredictable race, and we just have to try and do the best we can.”

Ryan joined road.cc in December 2021 and since then has kept the site’s readers and listeners informed and enthralled (well at least occasionally) on news, the live blog, and the road.cc Podcast. After boarding a wrong bus at the world championships and ruining a good pair of jeans at the cyclocross, he now serves as road.cc’s senior news writer. Before his foray into cycling journalism, he wallowed in the equally pitiless world of academia, where he wrote a book about Victorian politics and droned on about cycling and bikes to classes of bored students (while taking every chance he could get to talk about cycling in print or on the radio). He can be found riding his bike very slowly around the narrow, scenic country lanes of Co. Down.

Add new comment

15 comments

Avatar
Vo2Maxi | 1 month ago
1 like

How could Henderson have avoided this crash? Well, she couldn't have. She wasn't "trying to pass" on the wrong side, the Shimano car suddenly changed sides right after the corner, slammed on the brakes and cut her up. She didn't stand a chance.

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to Vo2Maxi | 1 month ago
0 likes
Vo2Maxi wrote:

How could Henderson have avoided this crash? Well, she couldn't have. She wasn't "trying to pass" on the wrong side, the Shimano car suddenly changed sides right after the corner, slammed on the brakes and cut her up. She didn't stand a chance.

Of course she could have avoided it, by staying at the back left of the neutral service car instead of trying to take the inside line round the corner. The driver is at fault for not checking properly before braking and moving to the side but Henderson was unquestionably in the wrong place and taking the wrong line and that contributed to the incident.

Avatar
lesterama replied to Rendel Harris | 1 month ago
1 like

Henderson took an appropriate line for the corner. Driver didn't check position before the corner. 75% on the driver, I'd say.

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to lesterama | 1 month ago
1 like
lesterama wrote:

Henderson took an appropriate line for the corner. Driver didn't check position before the corner. 75% on the driver, I'd say.

She took an appropriate line for the corner if there hadn't been any cars there...she's absolutely right in the middle of the driver's blindspot, at that speed and in the middle of a race the driver has to rely on cyclists knowing that they should stick to the left side of the car and never try to get up the inside. The driver was at fault after the bend for moving across without checking, but even then it has to be said that Henderson simply shouldn't have been there.

Avatar
eburtthebike | 1 month ago
3 likes

Those “medial emergencies" are the worst.  Best of luck Liz.

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to eburtthebike | 1 month ago
1 like
eburtthebike wrote:

Those “medial emergencies" are the worst.  Best of luck Liz.

Very hard to cycle with bad knees...

 

Avatar
galibiervelo | 1 month ago
1 like

Driving team cars is not for the faint hearted, riders on both sides and cornering faster than you. Riders understand this too.This is a racing incident only

Avatar
mdavidford replied to galibiervelo | 1 month ago
0 likes

Yeah - that was more 'bike hits car' than 'car hits bike', and all on Henderson really - trying to pass the wrong side, and on a corner.

Avatar
john_smith replied to mdavidford | 1 month ago
1 like

It was after the corner, and the car was a long way to the left, which would have made going round the outside extremely inconvenient. And did she try to pass or did the driver back off as he swerved and forgot to use his mirrors?

Avatar
mdavidford replied to john_smith | 1 month ago
0 likes

The collision was round the corner, but she's already diving up the inside as they go in to it. And inconvenient or not, you pass on the left.

Avatar
john_smith replied to mdavidford | 1 month ago
0 likes

Hard to tell whether she is "diving up the inside" or the car passed her shortly before the corner and then slowed down going into it.

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to john_smith | 1 month ago
3 likes

As someone who's been driving in the convoy for many years, that was a 50/50 blame. the driver had obviously been radioed to fix the flat, but if he'd been on his mirrors would have swung left pre-corner and allowed Anna to pass, that is what I would have done anyway. Then followed around and serviced the rider. Anna being the rider is going to take whatever line, but there is a reason you never pass on the "inside" of a car in the convoy, for those in the UK, that means going up the left of a car and abroad the right.

I'm just glad to see that the mechanic didn't manage to get the door open before Anna arrived, that could have been nasty. 

Avatar
Pub bike replied to Gkam84 | 1 month ago
2 likes

All the other motor vehicles were turning into the LH lane of the carriageway after the bend. The NSV initially followed that line taking the corner wide and crossing the centre line.  However, without then signalling right or checking behind the driver crossed back into the RH lane and then stopped immediately after a blind bend!  For sure it is normal to take the corner wide as that is expected on such a bend but not then to cut back in and then suddenly stop.

I think the driver is 100% at fault for three reasons:

1) The driver changed lanes twice without warning.  Once into the LH lane as they took the corner, and the second time back into the RH lane after the corner, both times without signalling and the second time definitely not looking out for any cyclists behind.  If the driver has first decided to move to the LH lane and started the manoevre by crossing the centre line they should complete the manoevre to avoid confusion.  

2) The driver stopped immediately after a sharp/blind bend without warning which is very bad practice.  Even with prior warning it is still not a good idea.

3) The driver didn't give the cyclist behind a clear route either to the left or the right because of the clumsy way they took the corner appearing to move into the LH lane and then veering to the right. This is a cycle race not a normal highway sitation and a cyclist shouldn't have to slow down because of a vehicle in front especially when the road is plenty wide enough for passing.  The motor vehicles should be helping riders go as fast as they like not slow them down.

Avatar
mdavidford replied to Pub bike | 1 month ago
0 likes

There are no 'lanes' in a bike race - the normal road markings don't apply. The location of the stop, just around a corner, was unfortunate (and the rider needing assistance probably should have gone a bit further along, but in the hustle of the race it's understandable it didn't occur to them). However, if Henderson had been correctly located on the other side of the car, then it moving across would have opened space for her to pass.

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to Pub bike | 1 month ago
0 likes

You need to understand what they were doing and their role in the race to see why they moved over to the right. That is where the Polish rider went to seek assitance, they had been radioed to service her. 

They should have, like I suggested, pulled over before the corner and let Anna take it, then serviced the rider

1, you don't give warning is racing. You can go anywhere that is safe to use on that circuit.

2, The driver stopped after the bend because he had been called to service the rider and that is where the rider decided she was safe to stop. 

3,  It is not a drivers job to help any riders go fast, they should have been aware that Anna was coming up on them quickly, but weren't. Anna should have been aware that she can corner quicker. But for the Polish rider pulling over right there, none of this would have happened, that is why it's a 50/50, no harm done to anyone, a learning experience for all. 

 

Latest Comments